Saturday, August 24, 2013

Отклонить американской пропаганде обрезания

Отклонить американской пропаганде обрезания




Америке пришлось Культура младенческой мужского обрезания в течение более 100 лет. Теперь, кажется, чтобы быть на медленное снижение, при этом многие американцы отказываются, чтобы он сделал для своих сыновей. Тем не менее, те американцы, которые не хотят, чтобы это произошло отчаянно пытается продвинуть обрезание не только в США, но остальной мир, в частности Африки. Правда, что большинство людей мира никогда не были обрезаны, они живут здоровые долгую жизнь с крайней плоти нетронутыми, и насладиться прелестями крайней плоти. Совсем недавно с появлением Интернета World-Wide Anti-Обрезание движение возникло, и Pro-Обрезание американцы пытаются защитить свои умирает медленной культурной практики мужского обрезания. Если вы посмотрите на факты, обрезание не удалось американцам в области, которую они в настоящее время делают такие требования, как пользу для здоровья. То, что вы найдете то, что Наций, которые отказываются обрезания, в частности первых народов мира, есть граждане, которые живут дольше, имеют более низкую младенческую смертность, снижение по ИППП и ВИЧ, иметь более здоровых детей и младенцев, чем в США, которые практикует обрезание на протяжении более ста лет. Я перечислил некоторые доказательства ниже.




В 2012 году Американская академия педиатрии выпустила свой Обрезание политике, который заявил, что преимущества обрезания перевешивают риски, и что медицинские страховые компании должны покрывать этой операции. Эта политика вызвала возмущение во всем мире, и ведущими педиатрами и ученые-медики со всего мира, пишет американский журнал Pediatrics заявив 2012 Обрезание Программное заявление AAP не был основан в доказательствах медицинских наук, но был документ, основанный на культурных предвзятости. и http://joseph4gi.blogspot.com.au/2013/03/out-of-line-aap-circumcision-policy.html




Американцы утверждали, что они выполняют младенческой обрезания, поскольку она имеет преимущества для здоровья, хорошо позволяет рассмотреть эти заявления пользы для здоровья от реальной жизни эпидемиологических результатов. Долголетие является общепризнанным в качестве одного из важнейших признаков здоровья человека и лица нации, если мы посмотрим на долголетие американцев которая 78yrs, можно было бы ожидать, что он будет выше, чем аналогичные Наций, которые не практикуют обрезание, но на самом деле все наоборот. Страны, которые не обрезать имеют намного более высокую долговечность. Долголетие Японии является 81.4yrs, долговечность Швеции 80,6 лет, Switzerlands Долголетие является 80.6years. На самом деле большая часть Европы, которая не обрежьте имеет более высокую продолжительность жизни, чем в США. Даже в США было сообщено в прессе, что американские Latino в которые обычно являются судья предупредил обрезать самые долговременные граждан США. Поэтому совершенно ясно, что младенческой Обрезание не удалась США на медико-санитарные меры долголетия.
Последний доклад ОЭСР по медицинским здоровья нации перечислены топ-30 стран с рейтингом 1 бытие лучших результатов и 30 худших следующим образом: Давайте начнем с рассмотрения здоровья категорию, поскольку здравоохранение очень много в новостях в США , и то, что происходит с ним сейчас так богато иллюстрирует значение строгая сортировочных Fullbrook о упрямых фактов. Показатели в этой категории, наряду с Соединенными Штатами рейтинга, являются: ожидаемая продолжительность жизни при рождении (24), ожидаемой продолжительности здоровой жизни при рождении (24 [связаны] из 29), вероятность не достижения возраста 60 ( 25), коэффициент младенческой смертности (25), ожирение (30), практикующих врачей на душу населения (23), больничных коек на душу населения (25 из 29), психиатрических коек на душу населения (25 из 29) .. На совокупный индекс показателей здравоохранения, поставляется в США на 28 место, опередив ... Турции и Мексике. Вы должны согласиться, что если cirumcision является предиктором здоровья, то она с треском проваливается в этом контексте, так как большинство стран высокий рейтинг, чем США обычно не обрезать своих мужчин.


Младенческая смертность является еще одной мерой общественного здравоохранения, и США делает очень плохо раз по сравнению с его не-цирк сверстниками, с гораздо более высокой младенческой смертности, чем страны ЕС и Японию. Смертности Коэффициент младенческой США составляет 6,4 смертей на живорожденных, против Швеции 2,8 смертей на живорожденных в Японии и в 3,2 смертей на живорожденных. Опять же большинство не-обрезать Европе имеет более низкую младенческую смертность, чем в США. Младенческая Обрезание не удалась США на медико-санитарные меры младенческой смертности.
Смерть от младенца обрезанию. Трагично, что младенцы умирают бессмысленной смертью каждый год в США от осложнений обрезания. Это является неопровержимым доказательством, что, когда дети умирают от предотвратимых смерти, потому что младенческая обрезание выборные процедуры, что он терпит неудачу Америки. Почему любой цивилизованной нации выполняют операции на здорового ребенка, что может привести к смерти?
Младенческая обрезание также не Америку ООН мера ребенка благополучия:
Организация Объединенных Наций мера детского благополучия = посмотрите на таблицу ниже:

Благополучия детей Таблица

1. Нидерланды

2. Швеция

3. Дания

4. Финляндия

5. Испания

6. Швейцария

7. Норвегия

8. Италия

9. Ирландии

10. Бельгия

11. Германия

12. Канада

13. Греция

14. Польша

15. Чешская республика

16. Франция

17. Португалия

18. Австрия

19. Венгрия

20. США **

19 Наций опережает США ** все номера для обрезать Наций. Из этого доказательства только кажется, чем обрезание младенцам делает нулевой вклад в благополучие детей. Эти данные бы предполагает, что есть и другие факторы, гораздо важнее, чем обрезание, которые участвуют в благополучие детей, и, что младенческая обрезание имеет нулевой вклад в благополучие детей.
(Http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=21566&Cr=unicef&Cr1)






Инфекции, передающиеся половым является еще одной мерой общественного здравоохранения, где младенческая обрезание не удалась США по сравнению с не-Обрезание народов Европы. В США есть 1200% выше, чем ВИЧ-инфекции No-Circ Финляндии (в печати) имеет 500% выше, чем ВИЧ-инфекции No-Circ Германии и 300% выше, чем ВИЧ-инфекции не цирк-Голландии. . В США в 2,7 раза Syphillus инфекциям, чем-чем не цирк Голландии. . В США есть 33 раз Gonnoreah инфекциям, чем-чем не цирк Голландии. . В США в 19 раз, чем инфекции Chlamydia No-Circ Голландии. Младенческая Обрезание не удалась США на медико-санитарные меры ставок ИППП.
(Защитники молодежи данных) http://www.advocatesforyouth.org/storage/advfy/documents/fsest.pdf

Еще одна претензия обрезанием сторонников в том, что circumcison предотвращает рак полового члена. Дании, которая не обрезание младенцев мужского пола его имеет более низкий уровень заболеваемости раком полового члена, чем в США, которая делает. Этот факт позволяет предположить, эпидемиологические есть более важные факторы, чем обрезание предотвращения рака полового члена. Другая неудача для детского обрезания.
Мужской гнев на детской обрезание проявляется в движении восстановлению крайней плоти и огромные Intactivist движения в США. Что мужчин крайней плоти восстановление их после того, как невольно circumcsed больше доказательств отказа в обрезании.




В медицинской эпидемиологии мы часто смотреть на лучших в мире результатов в отношении здоровья, определить resasons / практики, которые способствуют и часто маркировать это как золотой стандарт медицинской практике. Европа, которая не обрезание младенцев мужского пола его, имеет здоровые дети, мальчики, и мужчины, чем в США, который не обрезать ее младенцев. На эти меры сами по себе 5 Номера для обрезания младенцев будет считаться золотым стандартом медицинской практике, и можно сказать, что уровень младенческой обрезание как мера общественного здравоохранения является одной большой грандиозное поражение в США.
Таким образом, по крайней мере, и против своих собственных претензий ", что младенческая обрезание обеспечивает преимущества для здоровья", детского обрезания не удалось Америки, и если что-нибудь вполне можно предположить, что данные указывают на корреляцию с прямо противоположным (младенческой обрезание вызывает слабое здоровье результаты в первых народов мира). Тем не менее, гораздо более подробную и более дорогостоящие исследования должны будут определить достоверность корреляции между младенцем обрезания и более неблагоприятные исходы здоровья в первых народов мира. Номера для обрезания страны будут иметь нулевую мотивацию выделения ресурсов на эти исследования, и то обрезание Наций прочь были бы посвятить reseources чтобы узнать, что их религиозные и культурные медицинской практике на самом деле вредно для мужского здоровья. В сущности, как это происходит сейчас, это стихийное движение в Америке, где обычные люди через образование и готовность идти против культурных норм, защищая одного ребенка в то время, от младенца обрезание, чтобы в конечном итоге приведет практика отменена в США.
Ответственность лежит на промоутеров и profilgators обрезания доказать обратное, но на этих истинной жизни медицинского обрезания младенческой результатов не удалось Америки.
Всемирная организация здравоохранения 2007 является источником долголетия и данные младенческой смертности. Защитники молодежи является источником данных STI:
http://www.advocatesforyouth.org/storage/advfy/documents/fsest.pdf

Otklonit' amerikanskoy propagande obrezaniya





Amerike prishlos' Kul'tura mladencheskoy muzhskogo obrezaniya v techeniye boleye 100 let. Teper', kazhetsya, chtoby byt' na medlennoye snizheniye, pri etom mnogiye amerikantsy otkazyvayutsya, chtoby on sdelal dlya svoikh synovey. Tem ne meneye, te amerikantsy, kotoryye ne khotyat, chtoby eto proizoshlo otchayanno pytayetsya prodvinut' obrezaniye ne tol'ko v SSHA, no ostal'noy mir, v chastnosti Afriki. Pravda, chto bol'shinstvo lyudey mira nikogda ne byli obrezany, oni zhivut zdorovyye dolguyu zhizn' s krayney ploti netronutymi, i nasladit'sya prelestyami krayney ploti. Sovsem nedavno s poyavleniyem Interneta World-Wide Anti-Obrezaniye dvizheniye vozniklo, i Pro-Obrezaniye amerikantsy pytayutsya zashchitit' svoi umirayet medlennoy kul'turnoy praktiki muzhskogo obrezaniya. Yesli vy posmotrite na fakty, obrezaniye ne udalos' amerikantsam v oblasti, kotoruyu oni v nastoyashcheye vremya delayut takiye trebovaniya, kak pol'zu dlya zdorov'ya. To, chto vy naydete to, chto Natsiy, kotoryye otkazyvayutsya obrezaniya, v chastnosti pervykh narodov mira, yest' grazhdane, kotoryye zhivut dol'she, imeyut boleye nizkuyu mladencheskuyu smertnost', snizheniye po IPPP i VICH, imet' boleye zdorovykh detey i mladentsev, chem v SSHA, kotoryye praktikuyet obrezaniye na protyazhenii boleye sta let. YA perechislil nekotoryye dokazatel'stva nizhe.





V 2012 godu Amerikanskaya akademiya pediatrii vypustila svoy Obrezaniye politike, kotoryy zayavil, chto preimushchestva obrezaniya pereveshivayut riski, i chto meditsinskiye strakhovyye kompanii dolzhny pokryvat' etoy operatsii. Eta politika vyzvala vozmushcheniye vo vsem mire, i vedushchimi pediatrami i uchenyye-mediki so vsego mira, pishet amerikanskiy zhurnal Pediatrics zayaviv 2012 Obrezaniye Programmnoye zayavleniye AAP ne byl osnovan v dokazatel'stvakh meditsinskikh nauk, no byl dokument, osnovannyy na kul'turnykh predvzyatosti. i http://joseph4gi.blogspot.com.au/2013/03/out-of-line-aap-circumcision-policy.html





Amerikantsy utverzhdali, chto oni vypolnyayut mladencheskoy obrezaniya, poskol'ku ona imeyet preimushchestva dlya zdorov'ya, khorosho pozvolyayet rassmotret' eti zayavleniya pol'zy dlya zdorov'ya ot real'noy zhizni epidemiologicheskikh rezul'tatov. Dolgoletiye yavlyayetsya obshchepriznannym v kachestve odnogo iz vazhneyshikh priznakov zdorov'ya cheloveka i litsa natsii, yesli my posmotrim na dolgoletiye amerikantsev kotoraya 78yrs, mozhno bylo by ozhidat', chto on budet vyshe, chem analogichnyye Natsiy, kotoryye ne praktikuyut obrezaniye, no na samom dele vse naoborot. Strany, kotoryye ne obrezat' imeyut namnogo boleye vysokuyu dolgovechnost'. Dolgoletiye Yaponii yavlyayetsya 81.4yrs, dolgovechnost' Shvetsii 80,6 let, Switzerlands Dolgoletiye yavlyayetsya 80.6years. Na samom dele bol'shaya chast' Yevropy, kotoraya ne obrezh'te imeyet boleye vysokuyu prodolzhitel'nost' zhizni, chem v SSHA. Dazhe v SSHA bylo soobshcheno v presse, chto amerikanskiye Latino v kotoryye obychno yavlyayutsya sud'ya predupredil obrezat' samyye dolgovremennyye grazhdan SSHA. Poetomu sovershenno yasno, chto mladencheskoy Obrezaniye ne udalas' SSHA na mediko-sanitarnyye mery dolgoletiya.

Posledniy doklad OESR po meditsinskim zdorov'ya natsii perechisleny top-30 stran s reytingom 1 bytiye luchshikh rezul'tatov i 30 khudshikh sleduyushchim obrazom: Davayte nachnem s rassmotreniya zdorov'ya kategoriyu, poskol'ku zdravookhraneniye ochen' mnogo v novostyakh v SSHA , i to, chto proiskhodit s nim seychas tak bogato illyustriruyet znacheniye strogaya sortirovochnykh Fullbrook o upryamykh faktov. Pokazateli v etoy kategorii, naryadu s Soyedinennymi Shtatami reytinga, yavlyayutsya: ozhidayemaya prodolzhitel'nost' zhizni pri rozhdenii (24), ozhidayemoy prodolzhitel'nosti zdorovoy zhizni pri rozhdenii (24 [svyazany] iz 29), veroyatnost' ne dostizheniya vozrasta 60 ( 25), koeffitsiyent mladencheskoy smertnosti (25), ozhireniye (30), praktikuyushchikh vrachey na dushu naseleniya (23), bol'nichnykh koyek na dushu naseleniya (25 iz 29), psikhiatricheskikh koyek na dushu naseleniya (25 iz 29) .. Na sovokupnyy indeks pokazateley zdravookhraneniya, postavlyayetsya v SSHA na 28 mesto, operediv ... Turtsii i Meksike. Vy dolzhny soglasit'sya, chto yesli cirumcision yavlyayetsya prediktorom zdorov'ya, to ona s treskom provalivayetsya v etom kontekste, tak kak bol'shinstvo stran vysokiy reyting, chem SSHA obychno ne obrezat' svoikh muzhchin.



Mladencheskaya smertnost' yavlyayetsya yeshche odnoy meroy obshchestvennogo zdravookhraneniya, i SSHA delayet ochen' plokho raz po sravneniyu s yego ne-tsirk sverstnikami, s gorazdo boleye vysokoy mladencheskoy smertnosti, chem strany YES i Yaponiyu. Smertnosti Koeffitsiyent mladencheskoy SSHA sostavlyayet 6,4 smertey na zhivorozhdennykh, protiv Shvetsii 2,8 smertey na zhivorozhdennykh v Yaponii i v 3,2 smertey na zhivorozhdennykh. Opyat' zhe bol'shinstvo ne-obrezat' Yevrope imeyet boleye nizkuyu mladencheskuyu smertnost', chem v SSHA. Mladencheskaya Obrezaniye ne udalas' SSHA na mediko-sanitarnyye mery mladencheskoy smertnosti.

Smert' ot mladentsa obrezaniyu. Tragichno, chto mladentsy umirayut bessmyslennoy smert'yu kazhdyy god v SSHA ot oslozhneniy obrezaniya. Eto yavlyayetsya neoproverzhimym dokazatel'stvom, chto, kogda deti umirayut ot predotvratimykh smerti, potomu chto mladencheskaya obrezaniye vybornyye protsedury, chto on terpit neudachu Ameriki. Pochemu lyuboy tsivilizovannoy natsii vypolnyayut operatsii na zdorovogo rebenka, chto mozhet privesti k smerti?

Mladencheskaya obrezaniye takzhe ne Ameriku OON mera rebenka blagopoluchiya:

Organizatsiya Ob"yedinennykh Natsiy mera detskogo blagopoluchiya = posmotrite na tablitsu nizhe:


Blagopoluchiya detey Tablitsa


1. Niderlandy


2. Shvetsiya


3. Daniya


4. Finlyandiya


5. Ispaniya


6. Shveytsariya


7. Norvegiya


8. Italiya


9. Irlandii


10. Bel'giya


11. Germaniya


12. Kanada


13. Gretsiya


14. Pol'sha


15. Cheshskaya respublika


16. Frantsiya


17. Portugaliya


18. Avstriya


19. Vengriya


20. SSHA **


19 Natsiy operezhayet SSHA ** vse nomera dlya obrezat' Natsiy. Iz etogo dokazatel'stva tol'ko kazhetsya, chem obrezaniye mladentsam delayet nulevoy vklad v blagopoluchiye detey. Eti dannyye by predpolagayet, chto yest' i drugiye faktory, gorazdo vazhneye, chem obrezaniye, kotoryye uchastvuyut v blagopoluchiye detey, i, chto mladencheskaya obrezaniye imeyet nulevoy vklad v blagopoluchiye detey.
(Http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=21566&Cr=unicef&Cr1)







Infektsii, peredayushchiyesya polovym yavlyayetsya yeshche odnoy meroy obshchestvennogo zdravookhraneniya, gde mladencheskaya obrezaniye ne udalas' SSHA po sravneniyu s ne-Obrezaniye narodov Yevropy. V SSHA yest' 1200% vyshe, chem VICH-infektsii No-Circ Finlyandii (v pechati) imeyet 500% vyshe, chem VICH-infektsii No-Circ Germanii i 300% vyshe, chem VICH-infektsii ne tsirk-Gollandii. . V SSHA v 2,7 raza Syphillus infektsiyam, chem-chem ne tsirk Gollandii. . V SSHA yest' 33 raz Gonnoreah infektsiyam, chem-chem ne tsirk Gollandii. . V SSHA v 19 raz, chem infektsii Chlamydia No-Circ Gollandii. Mladencheskaya Obrezaniye ne udalas' SSHA na mediko-sanitarnyye mery stavok IPPP.
(Zashchitniki molodezhi dannykh) http://www.advocatesforyouth.org/storage/advfy/documents/fsest.pdf


Yeshche odna pretenziya obrezaniyem storonnikov v tom, chto circumcison predotvrashchayet rak polovogo chlena. Danii, kotoraya ne obrezaniye mladentsev muzhskogo pola yego imeyet boleye nizkiy uroven' zabolevayemosti rakom polovogo chlena, chem v SSHA, kotoraya delayet. Etot fakt pozvolyayet predpolozhit', epidemiologicheskiye yest' boleye vazhnyye faktory, chem obrezaniye predotvrashcheniya raka polovogo chlena. Drugaya neudacha dlya detskogo obrezaniya.

Muzhskoy gnev na detskoy obrezaniye proyavlyayetsya v dvizhenii vosstanovleniyu krayney ploti i ogromnyye Intactivist dvizheniya v SSHA. Chto muzhchin krayney ploti vosstanovleniye ikh posle togo, kak nevol'no circumcsed bol'she dokazatel'stv otkaza v obrezanii.





V meditsinskoy epidemiologii my chasto smotret' na luchshikh v mire rezul'tatov v otnoshenii zdorov'ya, opredelit' resasons / praktiki, kotoryye sposobstvuyut i chasto markirovat' eto kak zolotoy standart meditsinskoy praktike. Yevropa, kotoraya ne obrezaniye mladentsev muzhskogo pola yego, imeyet zdorovyye deti, mal'chiki, i muzhchiny, chem v SSHA, kotoryy ne obrezat' yeye mladentsev. Na eti mery sami po sebe 5 Nomera dlya obrezaniya mladentsev budet schitat'sya zolotym standartom meditsinskoy praktike, i mozhno skazat', chto uroven' mladencheskoy obrezaniye kak mera obshchestvennogo zdravookhraneniya yavlyayetsya odnoy bol'shoy grandioznoye porazheniye v SSHA.

Takim obrazom, po krayney mere, i protiv svoikh sobstvennykh pretenziy ", chto mladencheskaya obrezaniye obespechivayet preimushchestva dlya zdorov'ya", detskogo obrezaniya ne udalos' Ameriki, i yesli chto-nibud' vpolne mozhno predpolozhit', chto dannyye ukazyvayut na korrelyatsiyu s pryamo protivopolozhnym (mladencheskoy obrezaniye vyzyvayet slaboye zdorov'ye rezul'taty v pervykh narodov mira). Tem ne meneye, gorazdo boleye podrobnuyu i boleye dorogostoyashchiye issledovaniya dolzhny budut opredelit' dostovernost' korrelyatsii mezhdu mladentsem obrezaniya i boleye neblagopriyatnyye iskhody zdorov'ya v pervykh narodov mira. Nomera dlya obrezaniya strany budut imet' nulevuyu motivatsiyu vydeleniya resursov na eti issledovaniya, i to obrezaniye Natsiy proch' byli by posvyatit' reseources chtoby uznat', chto ikh religioznyye i kul'turnyye meditsinskoy praktike na samom dele vredno dlya muzhskogo zdorov'ya. V sushchnosti, kak eto proiskhodit seychas, eto stikhiynoye dvizheniye v Amerike, gde obychnyye lyudi cherez obrazovaniye i gotovnost' idti protiv kul'turnykh norm, zashchishchaya odnogo rebenka v to vremya, ot mladentsa obrezaniye, chtoby v konechnom itoge privedet praktika otmenena v SSHA.

Otvetstvennost' lezhit na promouterov i profilgators obrezaniya dokazat' obratnoye, no na etikh istinnoy zhizni meditsinskogo obrezaniya mladencheskoy rezul'tatov ne udalos' Ameriki.

Vsemirnaya organizatsiya zdravookhraneniya 2007 yavlyayetsya istochnikom dolgoletiya i dannyye mladencheskoy smertnosti. Zashchitniki molodezhi yavlyayetsya istochnikom dannykh STI:

http://www.advocatesforyouth.org/storage/advfy/documents/fsest.pdf

Wednesday, August 21, 2013

Reject American Circumcision Propaganda



 
 

Reject American Circumcision Propaganda

 

America has had a Culture of Infant Male Circumcision for over 100 years.  IT now appears to be on a slow decline, with many Americans refusing to have it done to their sons.  However, those Americans that do not want this to happen are desperately trying to promote circumcision not only in the USA but the rest of the world, in particular Africa.  The Truth is that Most Men of the world have never been circumcised, they live healthy long lives with Foreskin intact, and enjoy the pleasures of the Foreskin.  Most recently with the advent of the Internet a World-Wide Anti-Circumcision movement has arisen, and Pro-Circumcision Americans are trying to defend their slow dying cultural practice of male circumcision.   If you look at the facts, Circumcision has Failed Americans in the area that they currently make claims such as Health Benefits. What you will find is that Nations that refuse circumcision, in particular First World nations, have citizens that live longer, have lower infant mortality, lower STI’s and HIV, have healthier children and babies, than the USA which has practised circumcision for over a hundred years.  I have listed some of the evidence below.

 

In 2012 the American Academy of Pediatrics released its Circumcision Policy, which stated that the benefits of circumcision outweighed the risks, and that Health Insurance companies should cover this surgery.  This policy caused worldwide outrage, and leading Pediatricians and Medical Scientists from around the world, wrote to the American Journal of Pediatrics stating the The 2012 Circumcision Policy statement of the AAP was not based in the evidence of Medical Science but was a document based on cultural bias. http://knmg.artsennet.nl/Nieuws/Nieuwsarchief/Nieuwsbericht/International-physicians-protest-against-American-Academy-of-Pediatrics-policy-on-infant-male-circumcision.htm  and http://joseph4gi.blogspot.com.au/2013/03/out-of-line-aap-circumcision-policy.html

 

Americans have claimed they perform infant circumcision because it has health benefits, well lets examine these claims of health benefits against real life epidemiological outcomes. Longevity is universally recognised as one of the most important signs of the health of an individual and the individuals of a nation, if we look at Americans Longevity which is 78yrs, you would expect it to be higher than similar nations that do not practice Circumcision, but in fact the opposite is true. Countries that do not circumcise have much higher longevity. Japan’s Longevity is 81.4yrs, Sweden’s Longevity is 80.6 yrs, Switzerlands Longevity is 80.6years. In fact most of Europe which does not Circumcise has higher longevity than the USA. Even within the USA it has been reported in Press that American Latino's who generally dont circumcise are the longest lived USA citizens. Therefore it is very clear that Infant Circumcision has failed the USA on the health measure of Longevity.

The Latest OECD report on the medical health of nations lists the the top 30 countries with rankings 1 being best outcomes and 30 the worst read as follows:
Let's start off by considering the health category, since healthcare is very much in the news in the US, and what's happening with it now so richly illustrates the value of Fullbrook's austere marshalling of stubborn facts. The indicators in this category, along with the United States' ranking, are as follows: life expectancy at birth (24), healthy life expectancy at birth (24 [tied] out of 29), probability of not reaching the age of 60 (25), infant mortality rate (25), obesity (30), practicing physicians per capita (23), acute care hospital beds per capita (25 out of 29), psychiatric care beds per capita (25 out of 29).. On the combined index of health care indicators, the US comes in at 28, just ahead of ... Turkey and Mexico. You would have to agree that if cirumcision is a predictor of health, then it fails miserably in this context, as most nations ranked higher than the USA do not routinely circumcise their males.


Infant mortality is another measure of public health, and the USA does very poorly again compared to its no-circ peers, with much higher infant mortality than the EU nations & Japan. The USA infant mortality rate is 6.4 deaths per live births, versus Sweden 2.8 deaths per live births at and Japan at 3.2 deaths per live births. Again most of non-circumcising Europe has lower infant mortality than the USA. Infant Circumcision has failed the USA on the health measure of Infant Mortality.

Death from infant circumcision. Tragically, Babies die unnecessarily every year in the USA from the complications of circumcision. This is irrefutable evidence, that when babies die from a preventable death, because infant circumcision is an elective procedure, that it is failing America.  Why would any civilised nation perform surgery on a healthy baby that can cause death?

Infant circumcision has also failed America on a UN measure of child-well being:

United Nations measure of child well being = look at the table below:

CHILD WELL-BEING TABLE

1. Netherlands

2. Sweden

3. Denmark

4. Finland

5. Spain

6. Switzerland

7. Norway

8. Italy

9. Republic of Ireland

10. Belgium

11. Germany

12. Canada

13. Greece

14. Poland

15. Czech Republic

16. France

17. Portugal

18. Austria

19. Hungary

20. United States**

The 19 Nations ahead of the USA** are all non-circumcising nations. From this evidence alone it appears than circumcising infants makes zero contribution to child well-being. This data would suggests there are other factors far more important than circumcision which are involved in child well-being, and that infant circumcision has zero contribution to child well-being.
(
http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=21566&Cr=unicef&Cr1)


 

Sexually Transmitted Infections is another measure of Public Health where infant circumcision has failed the USA when compared to Non-Circumcision nations of Europe. The USA has 1200% higher HIV infections than No-Circ Finland (in Press) has 500% higher HIV infections than No-Circ Germany & 300% higher HIV infections than no-circ Holland. . The USA has 2.7 times the Syphillus infections than than no-circ Holland. . The USA has 33 times the Gonnoreah infections than than no-circ Holland. . The USA has 19 times the Chlamydia infections than No-Circ Holland. Infant Circumcision has failed the USA on the health measure of STI Infection rates.
(Advocates for Youth data)
http://www.advocatesforyouth.org/storage/advfy/documents/fsest.pdf


Another claim by Circumcision proponents is that circumcison prevents penile cancer. Denmark which doesnt circumcise its male infants has lower penile cancer rates than the USA which does. This epidemiological finding suggests there are more important factors than circumcision to preventing penile cancer. Another fail for infant circumcision.

Male anger at infant circumcision is seen in the foreskin restoration movement and the huge Intactivist movement in the USA. That men are restoring their foreskins after being involuntarily circumcsed is more evidence of circumcision's failure.

 

In medical epidemiology we often look to world's best health outcomes, identify the resasons/practices which contribute, and often label this as the gold standard medical practice. Europe which doesnt circumcise its male infants, has healthier infants, boys, and men, than the USA which does circumcise its infants. On these 5 measures alone Non-Circumcision of infants would be considered Gold Standard Medical practice, and it could be said that Infant Circumcision as a public health measure is one big monumental failure in the USA.

In summary, At the very least, and against its own claims "that infant circumcision provides health benefits", infant circumcision has failed America, and if anything one could speculate that the data indicates a correlation with the very opposite (infant circumcision causes poorer health outcomes in first world nations). However, much further detailed and more expensive research would be required to determine the validity of the correlation between infant circumcision and poorer health outcomes in first world nations. Non-Circumcising nations would have zero motivation to allocate resources to this research, and circumcision nations would be averse to devoting reseources to find out that their religious & cultural medical practice is actually harmful to male health. In essence as is the case now, it is a grass-roots movement in America where ordinary people through education and a willingness to go against cultural norms, by protecting one baby at a time from infant circumcision, that will eventually see the practice abolished in the USA.

The onus is on the promoters & profilgators of circumcision to prove otherwise, but on these true life medical outcomes infant circumcision has failed America.

The World Health Organisation 2007 is the source of Longevity and Infant Mortality data. Advocates for youth is the source of STI data:

http://www.advocatesforyouth.org/storage/advfy/documents/fsest.pdf

Tuesday, August 6, 2013

Adult Narcissism and Infant Male Circumcision



It is Narcissistic to put your own personal desires to cut another human's genitals, above and beyond the needs and personal desires of that human being, before they can choose the genitals they want for themselves.
It is Narcissistic to lack Empathy and Understanding of the consequences another has to live with based on your own personal desires to cut their genitals
It is totally Narcissistic to use your power, over someone who has no power, such as a powerless baby and to impose  your genital preference on them , by having their genitals surgically altered to your personal preference. 

Sure ignorance, cultural conditioning and other factors play a role, but dont under-estimate the role of narcissism in the continuance of infant male circumcision.

Saturday, May 11, 2013

The Dilemna about telling the Truth about Circumcision


Circumcision and Truth The Dilemna

The Dilemna of telling the truth about the harms of circumcision and the sequalae of removing a healthy functional sex organ in the male foreskin, is that it actually harms those that have been circumcised, in particular children and adolescents, and pro-circumcision adults in those Cultures just fight harder to defend it.  However, if the truth is not spoken, the harms of circumcision will never end.

With children and adolescents, as they are developing & vulnerable minors we want them to grow up feeling good about themselves.  If and when we tell the truth that circumcision removes a functional and pleasurable part of their sex organ, which would have made their penis function and feel better, we can create psychological pain and harm to self-esteem of those children or adolescents, or we can cause a highly irrational defensive reaction. This is an unintended consequence about telling the truth it may harm children and adolescents circumcised against their will, during a time of life theyre are forming an identity.

As for adults from circumcision cultures those that favour it or defend it, will go to extreme lengths to do so, leaving themselves open to charges of total irrationality when trying to dispute the truth about the harms of circumcision and the function of the foreskin.  Look at the previously esteemed organisationssuch as the American Academy of Pediatrics, that in order to defend circumcision they released a paper in support of circumcision which not only minimized the harms of circumcision but denied truth that the male foreskin had any sexual function or sexual pleasure, leaving themselves looking unprofessional and totally irrational among their peers.  The AAP circumcision policy even motivated conservative medical professionals from around the world to band together and to publicly condemn the irrational and unscientific defence of circumcision by the AAP.

My dilemma is not that we provoke defensive reactions by adults from circumcision cultures, that is to be expected, and if the truth is not spoken, the harms of circumcision will never end.  My Dilemna is how we protect vulnerable children, and adolescents when we speak the truth about circumcision.  They did not choose circumcision for themselves but had it imposed upon them, they are minors, and psychologically vulnerable.

The question is how do we speak about the truth circumcision and minimize the harm to our most vulnerable humans, children?

Wednesday, April 3, 2013

Myths Like circumcision is best done as a baby bec he wont remember the pain do my head in

The myth about "if circumcision is done as a baby he wont remember it" do my head in.  Firstly he may not have verbal memory ( A memory he can speak about) but he will certainly have sensory and pain memory as Taddio's pain and immunization studies found.  Taddio et al found circumcised babies have a much greater pain response at 6 month immunizations.   Secondly, if a therapeutic circumcision is required in childhood or adolescence, yes he'll feel pain but his brain will be developed enough for him to talk about it and understand it, which will both help to soothe the pain and manage it by asking for pain medication,  as well as intergrate it neurally because he will understand what the pain is all about.  Myths and Ignorance do my head in!!!!!!!!!

Wednesday, March 20, 2013

The AAP and the Tribal Psychology of Circumcision

Psychology of Tribe borrowed from= http://www.writingsonthewall.net/morality-of-groups-1

The AAP & psychology of tribes applied to circumcision with my additions in bold italics:

1.When acting in ways which relate primarily to their membership of a group, a person’s behaviour changes to reflect the beliefs and aspirations of the group rather than those of the individual. Therefore if the group cuts the genitals of its members to denote group membership, male or female, the aspirations of the group will take precedence over the aspirations of an individual, which leads to infant male circumcision, and FGM of female children. You find parents and in-particular mothers from circumcision cultures handing over their newborns to be cut, even when it goes against their instincts to protect their baby from harm..  The AAP in this instance has written a policy on circumcision to defend its tribal custom, even tho the paper was scientifically and ethically flawed and drawn criticism from its peers around the world.  It would rather face shame and ridicule from its non-tribal peers, than go against its own tribe.

2. Tribal Psychology, is an important trait from hunter gatherer times when strong tribal identity was essential to survival, but it’s necessary for any group to find ways to emphasize the characteristic of group membership because it’s that identification with the group which helps promote cooperation and selflessness in the behaviour of its members. In genital cutting cultures, circumcision is then seen as a ritual which not only denotes tribal membership, but at some level is seen as essential to the survival of a group, an act of selfnessness & co-operation. You can see how circumcision cultures & its scientific institutions such as the AAP in America with its 2012 circumcsion paper scour the world for pro-circumcision research and ignore or deny any validity to research which contradicts circumcision's  so called health benefits or any evidence that the foreskin is a functional sex organ.  HIV Circumcision researchers from the circumcision culture of America go and look for data, and even create experiments such as the African HIV trials, to show that circumcision is essential to human survival. Look at the circumstances of the development of the trials. Epidemiological data from Africa showed that some uncircumcised populations had lower HIV infections than circumcised populations, however, the scientists ignored those populations, and the experiments were conducted where the uncircumcised populations had higher hiv infections. The methodologies of the experiment favoured the cut group, and conflicting data minimized or ignored. This selection process and methodology allowed a greater chance for the a priori hypothesis to be confirmed that circumcision protects against hiv which will ensure survival of the group. When the data favoured the circumcision group they ended the trials early exagerrating the results.  And then the unrelenting use of this data by the Pro-Circumcisers who use what happened in high prevalence HIV Africa, data from the experiments with adult volunteers, as a justification to circumcise male infants in low prevalence hiv nations such as the USA.  The AAP, and scientists from Circumcison cultures avoid or hide the fact that EU & Japan which dont circumcise have much lower HIV/STI's than the USA which has highest adult circumcision rates in the developed world.

Negative Elements of Tribal Psychology with my additions in bold italics include:

  1. Grandiose tribal self image: one’s own tribe has certain positive characteristics.  Look at the 2012 AAP Circumcision Policy which has been highly criticised around the world.  Look at the messages in Pro-Circumcision Propaganda: Circumcision makes the tribe more hygienic and clean; Circumcision looks better; Circumcision is better for sex; Circumcision is healthier. Contrast this with actual world facts that no medical organisation in the world recommends routine circumcision for the above reasons nor agrees with any of the above premises, and people from non-circumcision EU & Japan are healthier, live longer have lower hiv/sti's, and view the intact penis as healthy and normal.
  2. The tribal shadow: other tribes are evil and inhuman. The AAP calls EU Pediatricians biased against circumcision. Pro-Circumcision propaganda abounds with the demonization of the foreskin and the uncircumcised. Contrast this with actual world facts that most of the world 70 to 75% rejects circumcision, and the healthiest nations with the healthiest people are uncircumcised.
  3. Group polarization Tribal identity gains dominance over that of an individual’s self identity in situations of tribal conflict and competition. The AAP gives priority to Parents Rights over its primamry patient the child. Pro-Circumcision uses the propaganda slogan of its the Parents Rights to decide on circumcision, denying the rights of the child to choose for himself. That intactivists are evil prople who want to deny parents rights. Contrast this with the strongest arguments against circumcision which are based on human rights and ethical grounds, that it needs to be the individuals right to choose when they are an adult and make an informed consent decision for themselves.  For the AAP to concede this would mean giving dominance to the individual over the tribe, which they have refused to do.
  4. Group think: humans have evolved a tendency to conform to the predominant beliefs and opinions of groups to which they belong. Holding opinions contrary to the consensus engenders stress in the individual, and carries with it the risk of social exclusion. The AAP formed a committee made up of individuals who favoured circumcision to write a policy statement on circumcision, ensuring group think predominated. . EU Pediatricians who disagree with the AAP are labelled as more biased than Americans, and individuals who are against circumcision are labelled by Pro-Circumcision propagandists as foreskin fetishists, evil people, and extremists.

The essay drew the following conclusions and I add my interpretation in bold italics:

  • Tribal group environments have been important in the evolution of the underpinnings of human psychology, and for that reason people are powerfully influenced by factors which reinforce group identity. Therefore we have a very difficult task ahead of us to convince those in the AAP that believe circumcision is important to group identity, that they have erred.  Look at how they have childishly and churlishly attacked EU Pediatricians.  . WE need to select and use our strategies carefully, and slowly emphasise that genital status has nothing to do with group identity in a modern world. That observance of individual human rights in the modern world, helps us belong to the world of civilised & moral human beings. Obviously one strategy is to use education and informed discussion to educate that the foreskin is normal and healthy and the circumcision harms & violates. The arguments that reinforce the essentiality of circumcision for survival have to be debunked, because they are such a powerful reinforcer, and why the ProCirc’s use fear as a motivator to circ. Also note how some Jews themselves have abandoned the circumcision rite for the brit shalom a non-cutting ceremony to admit membership to the jewish community. So the message here is that Tribal Elders and people of influence within Tribes can say "you dont have to cut to be a jew". "You dont have to be cut to Belong"  "You dont have to be cut to be OK"  "You dont have to be cut to be loved".
  • Identification with a group polarizes divisions between the group and a category of others who form the group’s enemies. Strategically, WE need to be careful if we are to persuade , we need to be careful as not to seem like "The other tribe" and that we are not the enemies. We can educate & say that belonging to the group of humanity or any social group is completely independent of genital status Cut or UnCut.
  • Individuals are inclined to conform their thinking to that of the group, even against their personal self interest. This is where individual human rights have to be emphasised, that group think cannot allow the violation of these rights. Note individual psychological defence, “I;m so glad I was circumcised as a baby” never matter they were denied their functional anatomy and they never had a say.  Education is the key here, combat myths with facts.
  • Leaders understand how to take advantage of this psychology with jingoistic posturing and celebration of romanticised historical icons. This creates a narrative for the group which engenders heightened levels of polarization and group think. This is where we have to Challenge medical organizations such as the AAP and their leaders, including  law-makers and politicians, to emphasise individual human rights over that of group cultural rights.  The AAP has cleverly used its status and the apparatus of scientific literature to favour its own tribal position, this needs to be strongly challenged, and using the EU Pediatricians criticism of the AAP 2012 Circumcision policy is a good resource.

Where this process of Tribal Psychology may have been an advantage to the survival of a tribe or the individuals which made up that tribe in the past, it is clearly not in the interests of the individuals in the modern world to blindly follow tribal traditions. For that reason it is essential that individuals become aware of this psychology and insist that politicians/medicos/law makers refrain from allowing circumcision to continue. It needs to be emphasised that Circumcision of babies and children male or female is not important for the survival of any group, and is a violation of the individual human rights of that individual. We need to educate how genital cutting rituals are outdated and have no relevance in modern societies when it come to group membership or tribal identity.  Elders can just say "You Belong with Intact Genitals, male or female". The modern world needs to give pre-eminence to individual human rights particularly those of children, and that they be protected from genital cutting practices. If adults want to choose to have their own genitals cut, then that is an individual choice they can make for themselves.

Many of the myths and beliefs around the importance of circumcision for tribal identity have existed for millenia and are deeply rooted in the human psyche, therefore the task of separating circumcision from tribal identity will not be an easy one, and requires patience and hard work.


Tribal Psychology has the potential to directly conflict with individual human rights. AMEN

Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Problems with RCT's & Circumcision

What you'll find those with a pro-circumcision agenda doing is that they cite that only data derived from RCT research is valid in determining the validity of any circumcision research outcomes. ie. if its not RCT derived it is not valid.

While RCT's tend to be the gold standard of research studies, they are not without fault, and can lead to very misleading future predictions, particlularly when the assumptions they are based on are incorrect.

1. The first incorrect assumption of the African RCT circumcision trials was blaming the male foreskin as the cause of HIV infections.  Because some African population groups of non-circumcised men, had higher HIV infection rates than circumcised populations, the male foreskin was seen as the predominant cause of the differences in HIV infection rates.  What the researchers ignored was the fact that many African circumcised populations had higher hiv infection rates than non-circumcised populations.  Therefore the correct assumption about the cause of sexually transmitted  HIV infections has to be behavioural, eg. unsafe sex with multiple sex partners.

2. The second incorrect assumption was that circumcision confers an absolute lifetime protection against HIV infection, and that an 18 to 24 month trial was enough to prove this.  WRONG, the studies needed to have been longitudinal, over a complete lifetime, to determine the validity of circumcisions protective effect over a lifetime. If as seems to be the case that circumcision in a highly controlled environment with extra resources, than are normally available in aAfrica, can confer a small delay in time before infection occurs, then the assumption of life-time protection is also WRONG.  The desperation of researchers, and particularly the WHO in trying to do something about the HIV epidemic in Africa, has led to premature endoresment of something the research did not find or prove, ie. lifetime protection against HIV.  The RCT's did not prove a lifetime protective effect from circumcision, there is no evidence from the RCT';s of this claim. 

3. The third incorrect assumption is that men wont change their behaviour after circumcision, believing they are protected from HIV, and therefore disinhibiting their behaviour and practicising less safe sex behaviour.  Recent evidence from Africa confirms behavioural disinhibition is already occurring.  Therefore the assumption that men wont change their behaviour which will increase risk is also wrong.

The WHO has endorsed medical circumcision in Africa becuase it is claiming circumcision will reduce millions of infections, but this is made on an assumption that is not proven and most probably incorrect.  If you just change the assumptions slightly, ie. that circumcision may increase behavioural dis-inhibition and increase in unsafe sex behaviours, then the reduced infections become meaningless.  If as most data shows, that circumcision does not provide a lifetime protective effect against infection, then the protective effect of circumcision is incorrect, and again the predictions of reduced infections are meaningless.

Lets look at some research evidence which disputes the lifetime protective effect of circumcision. For instance,there is much data from around the world that shows some circumcised populations have higher HIV infection rates, than non-circumcision populations.  The EU where circumcision is uncommon has much lower rates of HIV than the USA where circumcision is very common. What this tells us, is that over a lifetime, whatever protective effect circumcision may have, is insignificant over a whole life, and meaningless in populations where circumcised groups have higher HIV infections than non-circumcised pouplations.

Therefore if you set up RCT's to last 18 to 24 months, end them early, and resource them in ways that will never be available in real life, and the reality is that the protective effect of circumcision is only short term, lets say 12 to 24 months, & not effective over a lifetime of 30 to 50 years of sexual activity as claimed, And you advertise and convince men that the protective effect of circumcision is for a lifetime, then you have made a grave public health error. What you have done is created a false sense of securty, and potentially created an environment where behavioural disinhibition occurs, where circumcised populations begin to practice less safe sex, & you end up with a public health disaster with higher HIV infections.

RCT's as with Computers, are only as good as the theoretical assumptions they are based on, or the data that is put into them.  Its Basically garbage in & garbage out!!!!!!!!!!